Vital Football

Latest Wigan Athletic News

FIFA`s vote, Implications for Football???

FIFA`s vote, Implications for Football???

Yesterdays vote by FIFA on the proposal to restrict the number of none national players to five in a team`s starting line up by 2012 has already sparked a massive debate with a European spokesman stating that the proposal as they believe it is illegal under European Law based on discrimination on the basis of nationality.

A quick look on the European Commission website throws up the following statement;

"Regardless of your place of residence, as a European Union worker you are entitled to take up an activity as an employed person in any Member State under the same conditions as nationals .

Equal treatment applies to all conditions governing employment and work (e.g. remuneration, dismissal, occupational reintegration or re-employment after being unemployed).

The principle of equal treatment in access to employment implies that you have the same priority as nationals for access to employment in any Member State.

This means that national provisions limiting the number or percentage of foreigners who may be employed do not apply to you.

Consequently, when in a Member State the granting of any benefit to enterprises is subject to a minimum percentage of national workers, you are regarded as a national worker.

In addition, EC law states that any clause of a collective or individual agreement or of any other collective regulation concerning eligibility for employment, employment, remuneration and other conditions of work or dismissal shall be null and void in so far as it lays down or authorises discriminatory conditions in respect of workers who are nationals of other Member States."

The above paragraphs clearly indicate that the proposal would be illegal under the law and as a result the law would have to be changed which would affect all employees from other member nations not just footballers something which is clearly against the founding principles of the E.U. not just UEFA.

Mr Blatter is quoted in today`s Independent as saying he has a meeting with a speaker of the European parliament in June to discuss the way forward.

The aim of the proposal is to encourage clubs to develop more English players and strengthen the national side and has the support of almost all the FIFA delegates.

So if implemented how would this affect football teams?

An article in today`s Independent shows that based on the last day of the season`s starting line ups only four clubs, Villa, West Ham, Bolton and Newcastle would have met the criteria.

Arsenal had one English starter and Liverpool just two. Wigan had five.

To meet the quota clubs would not be able to play their best team but one with more English players in it. Wigan`s solution would be to bring Taylor into the starting line up instead of Boyce or Figueroa.

The argument is that by having more nationals in the teams it would improve the national team but how?

The ultimate in club football is the Champion`s league final which featured ten players eligible for England six from Manchester United and four from Chelsea who arguably would form the backbone of the national team(Scholes being the exception as he has retired from national football).

Given the fact that we didn`t qualify for Euro 2008 with the majority of these ten players in the squads` casts doubts on Mr Blatter`s proposals.

In the 1970's we failed to qualify for the World Cup finals when the majority of players in the top tier of English football were eligible to play for England

I believe that there would be several potential detrimental outcomes if this proposal is implemented

The first is a potential haemorrhage of English born players to the big four clubs to make up the numbers.

For example Chris Kirkland would probably sit on the United bench for most of the season only replacing Van Der Sar when United needed another English player due to an injury to Rooney, Ferdinand etc.

How does this inactivity for an England international improve the national game?

I also believe that this ruling would hit the smaller nations.

There are many English born players who play for the other home nations, Eire and the Caribbean nations who would have to opt for English nationality in order to get a game for their club side.

A look at the Wigan squad reveals Emerson Boyce born in Aylesbury plays for Bermuda, Kevin Kilbane born Preston and plays for Eire and Marlon King born Dulwich plays for Jamaica.

Multiply those three by another nineteen premier league clubs and you can see a massive loss of players to smaller nations.

Premier League clubs would also be reluctant to take players from lower leagues or smaller nations such as Honduras for the same reason.

The influence last season of Wilson Palacios cannot be underestimated, imagine if we had not been able to play him because we had to play an eligible Englishman instead.

If Mr Blatter gets his way this will have much farther reaching implications than the Bosman ruling. One thing for certain is that if adopted the game in England would be changed radically.

by baskerville

Vital Latics

Come and join us Latics fans

We are a Latics fans site run by the fans for the fans, what are you waiting for sign up and join in

It`s free, quick and carries no obligation whatsoever.

Have your say on the Latics Speyk forum

Participate in the polls and the Vital Fantasy League

It's easy to register , simply click the link and enjoy getting involved

Click here for the Latics Speyk forum

Date:Saturday May 31 2008
Time: 9:59AM


Theses crazy Uefa and Fifa officials are trying everything that they can to hit English football, we didnt hear this type of rhetoric when the Spaniards or the Italians were dominant, in the 70's we had Dutch club Ajax dominating European football, so to have the Germans and who can argue that Real Madrid didnt have the whole European Cup stitched up in the early days? This type of dominace is a cycle we have it at the moment but left alone other nations clubs WILL emerge and knock us off the mantle naturally, what we dont need is this beaurocratic B/S that Blatter and his cronies are spouting
31/05/2008 10:09:00
the problem is the other parts of Employment Law that Sport doesn't apply. Players cannot just resign at any point in their contract. Employers (clubs) can withhold their registration and demand a transfer fee (modern day slavery?). The error is in confusing the profession of being a footballer with that of being a plumber or a nurse. Clearly it is not, so Sport should be exempt. Those who choose to be sportspeople are already adequatedly compensated for their loss of freedom. It is anti_Premiership because of the vast numbers of foreign players here, far more than in Spain and in Italy. In 2003, three Italian clubs made the semi's but it wasn't considered a problem. And if successfully implemented clubs would invest far more in academies, invest in school visits and co-operation in local areas and the talent pool would deepen very very quickly.
31/05/2008 10:25:00
It is quite remarkable when going around the forums that the only teams supprters against this are the ones who have the most foreign players. The bottom line does appear to be that the big spending clubs in Europe will take this to the European courts and the motion will never see the light of day.
01/06/2008 09:41:00
Page 1/1
  1. 1

Login to post a comment

Recent Wigan Athletic Articles

Wigan without skipper Sam

The 26-year-old will miss the next two games

Match Officials - Walsall v Wigan

The Match Day officials for Wednesday's away trip to Walsall have been announced by the EFL.

Stats: Wigan Athletic v Southampton

All the stats from Wigan Athletic (0) vs (2) Southampton, DW Stadium, 18/3/18 Att: 17,110

It's Cup Time Again For Wigan Athletic, Saints Or Sinner?

With the FA Cup quarter final on the horizon we have a lot to look forward to on this week's edition of the PWU Latics podcast...

Wigan Athletic Archived Articles

Vital Latics articles from

Site Journalists

The Latic
no email

Current Poll (see more polls)

FA - Southampton MotM
Suggested By: Site Staff
Sub - Powell1%
Sub - Colclough1%
Sub - Hunt0%
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites
The Vital Football Members League
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Vital Football Comment

Recent Wigan Athletic Results (view all)

Wigan Athletic Fixtures

Vital Members League Table

7.jeffs right50
8.Made in Wigan 50
Write for Vital Football