Vital Football

Latest Wigan Atletic News

Charles N`Zogbia Sale - Who Called The Shots?

Charles N`Zogbia Sale - Who Called The Shots?




Vital Latics member Paul Thorp, aka Thorpyness takes a look at Charles N'Zogbia transfer, over to you Paul:

N'Zogbia sale - Who called the shots?

It has been speculated that we didn't need to sell, that we need to sell to buy, and that we need to sell to balance the books. I suspect that of the three options only three men really know what the position is: Dave Whelan, Roberto Martinez and chief Exec Jonathon Jackson. Even these three between them have come out with conflicting statements. Uncle Dave has said all sorts on his own.

Giving the position some consideration, I don't think it's that hard to get to a version of the truth that I suspect is plausible enough to be accurate.

The facts or accepted truths are as follows:

1) We argued over a price.
2) Charlie now plays for Villa.
3) He had one year left on his deal.
4) Charlie earned a considerable sum per week, which we now don't pay him.
5) The accepted 'truth', that isn't actually known to be fact is that the fee was about £9.5 million pounds.

Consider the obvious options then:

Option A - Charlie stays and similar new contract signed

We pay wages at a slightly increased rate, the extra cost is not much, the management aren't seen to climb down to his demands. We increase the sell on value due to the fact a new contract is in place. Requires massive co-operation of the player to achieve, he needs to want to stay, he needs to be prepared to remain pretty much on his current wages. Massive win for the club, as their costs aren't increased much and they get a massive profit when he's sold due to the longer contract being reflected in a sale price.
I think this the least likely to ever happen given some of the other things we 'know' about the player.

Option B - Charlie stays with a big pay rise

We then pay his wages at whatever figure would be agreed, 60K per week was rumoured, plus bonuses.

Wages cost approximately quarter of a million quid per £5K a week they are on.

£60K per week would then cost us £3 million over the year in wages for one bloke, who might be crocked before the window shuts.

There would then be a sell on fee, maybe £20 million. We'd then get his services and a profit of £17million, minus whatever bonuses would have to come out of this, and then whatever it takes to settle other players that this would upset, which cuts into that seemingly high profit. Requires co-operation of player.

Option C - We sell to Villa for £9.5 million.

We get £9.5 million in the bank, we also have £1.25million in wages (assuming £25k/week) that now doesn't need to be paid.

Cash available to play with £10.75 million, wage structure remains intact, the management credibility in enforcing their will is increased.

Money is available to bolster the squad, but we have no Charlie N'Zogbia.

Option D - Charlie stays and no new contract was signed.

We then pay his wages, and get his services for an extra 12 months.

For every £5K/week he was on this would cost the club quarter of a million pound.

Again assuming £25K, this would be £1.25 million cost over the year.

We would get no sell on value when he goes. Normally this 'loss' of sell on value is incalculable, because without an actual sale, anything else is a guess at a value. We do have a sale and we do know it was in the region of £9.5 million. If we'd kept him, we therefore would have been unable to realise the £9.5 million we just got off Villa. Even assuming you'd get full value out of the league and both cups and he played 50 games in the upcoming season, and got paid 50 weeks wages. The club would then lose out on £190,000 per game in sell on and another £25K per game in wages, or his weekly wage per game. If he played say 30 games, you`d payout/lose £358,000 per game from your balance sheet.

So effectively, fans didn't want to lose the player, rumours are the dressing room might have felt differently. If he wasn't willing to sign a new contract, on our terms then for the club to operate in it's best interests, and for 'the right thing for the football club' to happen, we had no choice but to sell at that price if he wasn't for signing an extension. We even did well to haggle him up.

Every statement that's come out of the club, fits with either we wanted option A, we've tried to keep him with a bit of B, but not too much, we're not having D, so C it was.

To answer the title, who called the shots - We did! And as much as I've enjoyed watching him play, I hope he regrets going.



Bookmark and Share



Join The Vital Debate







Latics and Proud

Fancy writing an article about the Latics? Why not get in touch, we are always looking for new contributors, after all we are all Latics fans here and want to get the Latics message to the world, so if you have a favourite match or Latics memory get it jotted down, or whatever you want to say put it into an email and send it to us here at Vital Wigan

To get your article published just click here and we will put it onto the site





Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Writer:Paul Thorp
Date:Sunday August 7 2011
Time: 7:00AM

Comments

0
excellent article. well said.
taco
07/08/2011 04:56:00
0
Charles was demanding 60k a week to stay, Dave said there is no money left, So Charles went, it's as simple as that, that isn't rumoured, both player and chairman have said that between them.
Villa 4 Ever
07/08/2011 09:41:00
0
We can't or we won't break the bank ? I'm not privvy to the interviews in question so wouldn't like to commit. Whichever one it is, much as Charlie is a handy player, I'd rather see the club play safe.
thorpyness
07/08/2011 09:57:00
0
Relegation time for Latics!....oh and no I didn't read the article.I have only one lifetime.
Dannism
07/08/2011 10:56:00
0
We did the right thing. Whelan could have met Charlie's wage demands, but is it really worth crippling our wage structure for the sake of one player?
J_Mo
07/08/2011 13:23:00
0
it dos`nt matter what options you put in frount of the paying latics fan what matter is was he happy at the dw or was he not because if he wasn`t then he`s better of were he his and letts get on with what we have in frount of us a large premier hill to climb.are you reading this uncle dave.
laticspride
07/08/2011 14:15:00
0
How can you sell your best player and expect to survive? No,No no, I am not asking you. I am asking your Chairman...
bluemillionaire
09/08/2011 11:00:00
0
Ok. son not really, I have calmed down now. Victor Moses is another very talented player
bluemillionaire
09/08/2011 11:18:00
Page 1/1
  1. 1

Login to post a comment

Recent Wigan Athletic Articles

Dan's Big Game Report - Sheffield United 0 Latics 2

'I've done it, Grandad,' he said, slamming down the phone receiver.
'Done what, Grandson? The transfer window has been closed for five days now.'

'I've signed Nando's for Wiga

Video Highlights - Sheffield United 0 Wigan Athletic 2

The goals and highlights from Latics away win at Sheffield United:

Stats: Sheffield United v Wigan Athletic

All the stats from Sheffield United (0) vs (2) Wigan Athletic, Bramall Lane, 06/02/16 3pm Att: 20,304

Chris McCann Vital Latics Man Of The Match v Port Vale

Chris McCann has been voted the Vital Latics man of the match for his performance in last weekend's 3-0 win over Port Vale

Archived Vital Latics Articles

Vital Latics articles from

Site Journalists

Barry Worthington
Profile
Dan Farrimond (JWAW)
Profile
Adam Convery
Profile
Frank Ford
Profile
Noel Wards Leg
Profile

Current Poll (see more polls)

Man Of The Match v Sheffield United
Suggested By: Jimmy Crankie
Jussi Jääskeläinen1%
Donervon Daniels0%
Craig Morgan0%
Jason Pearce0%
Chris McCann0%
David Perkins8%
Sam Morsy33%
Max Power8%
Yanic Wildschut50%
Conor McAleny0%
Will Grigg0%
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites

League Table

# Team P W D L Pts. GD
1 Burton 29 19 3 7 60 16
2 Walsall 29 16 8 5 56 17
3 Wigan 30 15 10 5 55 21
4 Gillingham 30 16 7 7 55 19
5 Coventry 29 13 9 7 48 16
6 Millwall 29 14 5 10 47 9
7 Southend 29 13 8 8 47 6
8 Peterborough 29 13 5 11 44 13
9 Port Vale 30 12 7 11 43 -1
10 Sheff Utd 29 11 9 9 42 4
11 Bradford 28 11 8 9 41 -3
12 Barnsley 28 12 3 13 39 3
13 Scunthorpe 28 11 5 12 38 -4
14 Rochdale 28 10 7 11 37 -2
15 Bury 27 10 7 10 37 -4
16 Doncaster 29 9 9 11 36 -4
17 Swindon 30 10 6 14 36 -5
18 Blackpool 29 9 6 14 33 -7
19 Chesterfield 29 9 3 17 30 -11
20 Shrewsbury 29 8 5 16 29 -15
21 Fleetwood 27 7 7 13 28 -3
22 Crewe 29 6 8 15 26 -20
23 Oldham 27 4 12 11 24 -13
24 Colchester 29 5 7 17 22 -32
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News

Wigan Athletic Fixtures (view all)

Feb 13 2016 3:00PM : Oldham Athletic (H)
Sky Bet League One
Feb 20 2016 3:00PM : Walsall (a)
Sky Bet League One
Feb 27 2016 3:00PM : Bury (H)
Sky Bet League One
Mar 1 2016 7:45PM : Millwall (a)
Sky Bet League One
Mar 5 2016 3:00PM : Peterborough United (H)
Sky Bet League One
Mar 12 2016 3:00PM : Colchester United (a)
Sky Bet League One

Recent Wigan Athletic Results (view all)

Vital Members League Table

RankNamePoints
1.BrickLatic64
2.Thorpyness57
3.Moonay50
4.Whittleblue47
5.Noel Wards Leg42
6.hindleymonwafc38
7.GrimReaper8719
8.1henski17
9.bensourhero17
10.TRUE BELIEVER17