Vital Football

Latest Wigan Atletic News

Hot Topic - Rotation

Hot Topic - Rotation




Vital Latics' Paul Thorp, aka thorpyness, discusses the latest 'hot topic' - rotation:

As playoff qualification looms into view, the latest hot topic on everybody lips has been that of squad rotation as we've approached the line. There are a number of supporters questioning whether Uwe is doing the right thing constantly changing the team, advocating that you should play your best 11 every game. As ever with most fan based complaints, they are far more likely to emerge than they were during the long winning streak, when complaints about squad rotation were few and far between.

Those that oppose rotation usually advocate one of two approaches. Firstly you can select your best 10 outfield, fit them into a system, and that's how it's done. Others will tell you it's best to pick a system, then select the best player you have for each position, play them every game and you will go sailing up the league. There is an element of undisputable sense about 'picking your best eleven', and it's so obvious that it sounds like it must be the right thing to do. That is provided you keep it simple and take it at face value. It's only once you get into any level of detail that it becomes clear that it's utter nonsense to even attempt anything other than to rotate your squad.

Picking your 'best 11' all depends upon how you define best, and that's something the moaners conveniently forget about whilst venting their complaints about over rotation. Lets for the sake of argument assume we've got a consensus in our hypothetical boot room and we know who our starting 'best 11' is. The next question should start you thinking about what the opposition strengths and weaknesses are and do they match up to the eleven we agreed on. Are defensive minded full backs better for this game than attacking ones, or would being able to get down the flanks make you a better player for this match than somebody that can't or doesn't bomb forward? Is it better to play two strikers, or one with midfield support, wing backs and a back two, or a back four? Unless you want to be flexible with personnel and rotate your squad, you're going to be asking somebody to play out of position.

Tiredness and fitness are things which also crop up regularly in discussions about rotation. My favourite phrase of the grumbling classes being 'These lads are paid small fortunes, they should be able to run all day, I'd bloody run all day for that much'. It is correct that as professional athletes the squad should be better able to cope with the physical demands of professional football than you or I can, but as anybody that's done exercise of any level will know, it's equally obvious that you're not able to perform to your best until you've properly recovered from your last exertion, don't believe me , ask your partner. No footballer could play a second game at their optimum intensity, or 'best' if you like, until they have recovered from the first game. No pay packet or amount of training will reduce their recovery time below a certain human limit, and then of course we're all different and have different individual recovery rates. So what happens when a second game comes before somebody has recovered fully from the last one? Are they still then considered the best player to use in that position even though they are not really fully ready? Well if you don't want to rotate your squad, you might have to stick to your guns and say they have to play, as they are in the best 11. The problem with this is that it's been proven that playing when tired from the previous game makes you increasingly prone to injury. So with two games a week for most of the season, it's almost impossible not to rotate. And that's without considering knocks and bruises. Bear in mind we've been without Shaun Maloney for most of the season, because he wasn't rested when he needed it, and things got to the point where he needed the operation that's laid him up.

Whilst injuries can happen any time, and you can rotate to try and reduce the chances, you can't guarantee prevention. Some injuries just happen as Ben Watson and Chris McCann will attest. It is however handy to have a player that's recently seen first team action and is fairly sharp ready to come in. The same goes for a rotation policy giving a youth player some experience and the chance to prove himself, or are you expecting him to suddenly, be one of your best players by magic. Both are options rotation gives you that 'pick your best 11' doesn't. Quite simply to try and pick your best 11 for every game might sound so obvious it has to be true, in truth it's utter madness to employ it all the time. Currently, touch wood, we've got as full a squad as we could have hoped for and some of that is down to luck, but a huge chunk is because Uwe is not frightened to rotate players. Now you could argue that we would already be secure in a confirmed playoff spot if we'd always played our best 11 players but it's hypothetical, I'd argue we might have more than two long term injuries.

I am happy that Uwe has rotated during the regular season, but going into the playoff, I suspect the 'pick your best 11' advocates will also be happy, because the thought processes and considerations in selection all change. If you don't get a result today, then you don't get to play the next game. It makes it worth risking a player for the benefits of a more stable line up in favour of continuity. If a player gets injured, you don't then need him in three days for the next game, it's in three months for pre-season.

Uwe Rosler has brilliantly balanced the need to use players to get points, and giving them a rest to try and keep them off the treatment table and available for the rest of the season. When Uwe took over, and we were in 11th spot, the aim was to make the playoffs. We're going to achieve that target, with a squad that has proven it can adapt to different situations and formations. We have a squad where all players have played a part, are ready to play a further part, and most importantly we have a squad that have been points better than anyone else around us for the second half of the season. We fear nobody.

Paul Thorp








Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Writer:Barry Worthington
Date:Sunday April 27 2014
Time: 7:00AM

Comments

0
Can't say that i'me a fan of the rotation setup as I think that I makes strangers of each other not no what each player will in front of the goal mouth is not a good idea if you ask me the only place that rotation works is when you play in Europe and domestic at the same time.this is what we saw Alex Ferguson do with great effect.
BlueGoose
27/04/2014 14:50:00
Page 1/1
  1. 1

Login to post a comment

Recent Wigan Athletic Articles

Any Previous? Latics v Oldham Athletic

Down the years there haven't been too many meetings between the two Latics, the first one coming in a League Division 2 encounter back in November 1997

Millwall Away Tickets On Sale From Saturday

Latics have released details of the match day tickets and allocation for the away trip to Millwall on Tuesday 1st March

PWU Latics Podcast - Muddy Water Blues

The pitch! What on earth was going on, we were set to be renamed the Muddy Water Blues until David Sharpe stepped in and ordered a re-lay.

Meet The Ref - Latics v Oldham - Nigel Miller

The 'Battle of the Latics' on Saturday when Oldham visit the DW Stadium will be refereed by County Durham's very own Nigel Miller

Archived Vital Latics Articles

Vital Latics articles from

Site Journalists

Barry Worthington
Profile
Dan Farrimond (JWAW)
Profile
Adam Convery
Profile
Frank Ford
Profile
Noel Wards Leg
Profile

Current Poll (see more polls)

Man Of The Match v Sheffield United
Suggested By: Jimmy Crankie
Jussi Jääskeläinen4%
Donervon Daniels2%
Craig Morgan2%
Jason Pearce6%
Chris McCann2%
David Perkins6%
Sam Morsy20%
Max Power4%
Yanic Wildschut46%
Conor McAleny6%
Will Grigg2%
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites

League Table

# Team P W D L Pts. GD
1 Burton 29 19 3 7 60 16
2 Walsall 29 16 8 5 56 17
3 Wigan 30 15 10 5 55 21
4 Gillingham 30 16 7 7 55 19
5 Coventry 30 13 10 7 49 16
6 Millwall 29 14 5 10 47 9
7 Southend 29 13 8 8 47 6
8 Peterborough 29 13 5 11 44 13
9 Port Vale 31 12 8 11 44 -1
10 Barnsley 29 13 3 13 42 6
11 Sheff Utd 29 11 9 9 42 4
12 Bradford 28 11 8 9 41 -3
13 Scunthorpe 28 11 5 12 38 -4
14 Rochdale 28 10 7 11 37 -2
15 Bury 28 10 7 11 37 -7
16 Doncaster 29 9 9 11 36 -4
17 Swindon 30 10 6 14 36 -5
18 Blackpool 29 9 6 14 33 -7
19 Chesterfield 29 9 3 17 30 -11
20 Shrewsbury 30 8 6 16 30 -15
21 Fleetwood 28 7 8 13 29 -3
22 Crewe 29 6 8 15 26 -20
23 Oldham 27 4 12 11 24 -13
24 Colchester 29 5 7 17 22 -32
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News

Wigan Athletic Fixtures (view all)

Feb 13 2016 3:00PM : Oldham Athletic (H)
Sky Bet League One
Feb 20 2016 3:00PM : Walsall (a)
Sky Bet League One
Feb 27 2016 3:00PM : Bury (H)
Sky Bet League One
Mar 1 2016 7:45PM : Millwall (a)
Sky Bet League One
Mar 5 2016 3:00PM : Peterborough United (H)
Sky Bet League One
Mar 12 2016 3:00PM : Colchester United (a)
Sky Bet League One

Recent Wigan Athletic Results (view all)

Vital Members League Table

RankNamePoints
1.BrickLatic128
2.Moonay90
3.Thorpyness81
4.Whittleblue70
5.Noel Wards Leg60
6.hindleymonwafc57
7.JJ_WAFC34
8.TRUE BELIEVER29
9.Marksparko27
10.GrimReaper8726