Wigan Athletic - Lack of depth cruelly exposed as Wigan crash out.
UK time is: 14:11:23
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

Tottenham Hotspur 3 - Wigan Athletic 1

White Hart Lane, London

2/1/2009 8pm

Attendance: 34,040

Lack of depth cruelly exposed as Wigan crash out.

Steve Bruce made seven changes to the team that beat Bolton on Monday,three enforced and four volountary and saw his lack of squad depth painfully and cruelly exposed.

In came Camara,Kapo and Brown for Zaki, Heskey and Cattermole with Bruce opting to rest Melchiot, Pollitt, Taylor and Figueroa replacing them with Boyce, Kingson, De Ridder and Kilbane.

Of the seven changes only Camara, Brown and Boyce looked worthy of a place ina premier league team with the others merely an embarassment.

It is testimony to the other seven players therefore that Latics were in the game, right until the death against an awful Spurs side, who must surely be there for the taking when we play them at the JJB, in just over a week's time.

The first half saw lots of effort and commitment from Latics but very few chances, the best falling to Camara in the fifth minute when he headed narrowly wide.

At the other end Kingson looked comfortable but was in truth very rarely tested. Latics passed the ball around well with Scharner and Bramble looking in control at the back and Brown and Palacios industrious in midfield. Up front Camara worked hard but was given very little chances.

Half time came and in truth the game so far wasn't a great advert for the magic of the F.A.Cup.

The second half started in muCh the same way as the first, however the game was changed by the pace of Campbell and the clumsiness of Kingson. Campbell beat the offside trap and raced into the penalty area, he appeared to be going wide and Bramble was racing back to cover.However a clumsy lunge from Kingson clipped Campbell, who fell theatrically and Mr Wiley awarded a penalty which Pavlyuchenko buried with ease.

Latics attempted to hit back quickly but Scharner's shot was blocked by Pavlyuchenko.

Latics were again hit by a sucker punch. A quick clearence by Gomes from a Wigan set piece fell to O Hara, who broke down the left, where Figueroa was missing and fired past Kingson who flailed at the ball without touching it. The ball hit the post and fell to Modric who on his knees and he headed the ball into an empty net.

This goal was controversial, in that Figueroa was lying injured in the Spurs penalty area. Mr Wiley didnt stop play but previously had stopped play, when Zakora was injured in the lower abdomen.

Latics didn't give up and Camara's industry was rewarded, when Cwyka shot on the turn, which came free to Camara who fired past Gomes.

Latics pushed for an equiliser, however Spurs sealed the victory, when Pavlyuchenko shot straight at Kingson from outside the area, who contrived to miss it, to seal a miserable performance on his debut.

Star Player

Paul Scharner.Defended well and looked dangerous in attack.

Player Ratings

Richard Kingson...4/10

Nowhere near Premier League quality. A debut he will never forget for all the wrong reasons.

Emerson Boyce...7/10

A usual ' steaddie eddie' performance.

Kevin Kilbane...5/10

Looked off the pace .

Paul Scharner...8/10

A totally commited performance from the big Austrian.

Titus Bramble...7/10

Solid as a rock.

Antonio Valencia...6/10

A quiet performance but still Wigan's most creative outlet.

Micheal Brown...6/10

Kept trying all night and didn't get booked.

Wilson Palacios...6/10

Kept trying and got booked again.

Daniel De Ridder...4/10

Must be released in the transfer window. Has nowhere near any of the attributes needed for a Premeir League player.

Olivier Kapo...3/10

His most telling contribution was jogging off when substituted. Another one to go this month please

Henri Camara...6/10

He may want away but at least he tried and deserved a goal for his effort.

Thomas Cwyka...6/10

Looked sharper than soem of his more illustrious team mates.

Maynor Figueroa...6/10

Had little chance to shine.

Erik Edman...5/10

Good to see him back on the field.

Manager Rating

Steve Bruce....5/10 His gamble of using squad players backfired badly, exposing his lack of depth within the squad.

Need to increas the qua;lity of the squad

Too many players Kapo, De Ridder, Kilbane, Kingson are not good enough to be at the club. Bruce needs to bring in quality replacements as well as holding onto the quality players such as Zaki and Valencia.

The fans

Fewer than 200 made the long trip to London and have a right to feel short changed by the decision not to feel the strongest possible side, thereby proving how much influence and power, the Premier League has over the other domestic competitions.

The Journalist

Writer: Baskerville Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Friday January 2 2009

Time: 10:58PM

Your Comments (oldest first)

Change to most recent first
Sorry Brucie a poor team selection, DeRidder wouldnt get in my 5-a-side team
Report Abuse
02/01/2009 23:15:00

i think the " we don't need to bring anyone in in the window," may need revising to we need at least 7. If Zakii, Heskey are out long term and we pick up any more injuries we are in deep trouble. Still now we know why we had two keepers on the bench recently instead of Kapo
Report Abuse
02/01/2009 23:21:00

obviously im happy with the win, the performance could of beem better truth be told......if we scored all our chances it would of been 8-1.....
Report Abuse
02/01/2009 23:26:00

if there's one thing that i know about wigan , it's that valencia is the MVP of the team , but that's only when he's playing as a right wing , every time bruce moves him 2 the left hand side he becomes an average player , so can anybody tell me why did bruce waste his most powerful weapon (valencia on the right hand side ) ???????????
Report Abuse
02/01/2009 23:26:00

Bruce wasnt up for this game tonight you can tell with the side he put out, it'll be a different story at the JJB next Sunday (hopefully) 8-1 lilywhites101??? look at the stats we both had the same number of goal attempts so it could have been 15-15
Report Abuse
02/01/2009 23:32:00

Have to say Baskerville,to be honest 3-1 flattered us a little,it was a good battling display by a weakened Wigan team.I think you're being harsh on your keeper though,he made a couple of decent saves,Campbell did what any decent striker would do for the pen,made the most of minimal contact,and he was unsighted by his own defender in the lead up to another goal.
Report Abuse
03/01/2009 01:43:00


Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. worbo 82
2. hindleymonwafc 67
3. Thorpyness 55
4. 1henski 54
5. Yon Mon 49
6. nottinghamlatic 45
7. Whittleblue 42
8. Moonay 31
9. Lazysid 29
10. Sortitout 28

League Results (view all)

Latest Results
Wigan 0 - 1 Burton
Wigan 1 - 0 Shrewsbury
Rochdale 0 - 2 Wigan
Wigan 1 - 0 Swindon
Bradford 1 - 1 Wigan
Peterborough 2 - 3 Wigan

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
2. Gillingham 19 11 4 4 14 37
3. Burton 18 11 2 5 3 35
4. Walsall 18 9 6 3 13 33
5. Wigan 19 9 6 4 10 33
6. Bradford 19 8 7 4 3 31
7. Peterborough 19 9 3 7 11 30
8. Southend 19 8 6 5 3 30

Wigan Athletic Fixtures (view all)

Breaking League News

League One - Fleetwood 2-1 Millwall
Fleetwood : 25/11/2015 14:09:01
League One - Doncaster 3-0 Chesterfield
Chesterfield : 25/11/2015 14:03:00
City Boss Mowbray Hails Performance
Coventry : 25/11/2015 12:39:00
Video - Shrewsbury Highlights (h)
Sheff Utd : 25/11/2015 12:27:01
Video - Fleetwood Highlights (a)
Millwall : 25/11/2015 12:25:01

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Tonights Big Game Winners?
Suggested By:  Burton Wafers
Latics 54%
Burton Albion 29%
Draw 17%